Compare Secret Santa generators

Create your Secret Santa draw Free, no signup needed, email optional.

Every page here compares this generator with a popular alternative, using each tool's own public pages as of November 2026. We make secretsanta.name, so we also say where the others are better: gift finders and apps are their strengths; no account needed, private links, anonymous messages the organizer can't read, simple wish lists and rules that are checked are ours.

The short version

If…Use
You want a gift finder and an appDrawNames or Elfster
Your family already shares lists on GiftsterGiftster
No account needed, no emails, couples kept apart, simple wish lists, anonymous messages the organizer can't read, and a draw that always respects the rulessecretsanta.name
A Secret Santa bot inside Slack or Discord, with the organizer never seeing the pairsSlack app · Discord bot

Start a free draw No signup. Takes about two minutes.

Accounts, wish lists and who sees the full list

ToolAccountEmail neededExclusionsWish listsWho can see the full list
secretsanta.nameNo (optional)No (optional)Yes, checked by a solverYesOrganizer and participants with an account, after the date (opt-in); nobody by default
DrawNamesNoWebsite: yes; app: noYes (4+ people)YesOrganizer, after the date
ElfsterOrganizer: yesUsuallyYesYesNobody
GiftsterYesYesYesYesNobody
Secret Santa OrganizerNoUsuallyYesYesNot stated
SecretSantaMatchNoNoYesYesNot stated

From each tool's own pages as of November 2026. Details in the best free generators comparison.

What we check on every tool

  • Does the organizer need an account? Do participants?
  • Do you have to collect everyone's email address?
  • How exclusions work (couples, households, one-way rules) and what happens when they can't all be met.
  • Who can see the full list of who gives to whom, and when.
  • Extras (wish lists, messages, apps) and how the tool makes money (ads, commissions, paid upgrades).

How this Slack app compares

Several tools help you run a Secret Santa in Slack. The facts below are taken from each product's own public pages as of November 2026. We make the secretsanta.name app, so we also say where the others are stronger.

If you would rather not install anything, the website still runs a private-link draw with no account.

secretsanta.namesecret-santa.teamTriviaFluky
What it isSecret Santa Draw, a Secret Santa Slack bot plus a website: type /secretsanta in a channelA chat app for Slack, Discord and Cisco Webex (listed in the Slack Marketplace as Secret Santa 2.0)A Secret Santa feature inside Trivia's team-bonding Slack appA website, not a bot: you copy a Slack-formatted message with one private link per person
AccountNo (optional)No registration, according to their siteUsed from Slack (by installing Trivia)No accounts, according to their page
Wish listsYes, on each person's private pageTheir page does not sayYesYes
Who can see the full listNobody in Slack draws, including the organizer. On the website: nobody by default, or the organizer and participants with an account after the date (opt-in)The organizer can check the repartition and shuffle again, per their FAQ, and later retrieve it with a codeTheir page does not sayNobody, including the organizer, per their page
Install a Slack app?Yes, from this page (a Marketplace listing is pending)Yes; it is on the Slack MarketplaceYes, as part of TriviaNo; there is no bot to install and no admin approval
ExclusionsAvoid the same Slack user group; on the website, households and one-way or two-way rulesYes: pairs who must not be matchedNot stated on that pageYes: pairs who should not draw each other
Price (as they state it)Free, no ads and no paid planFree, with no registration, paid plan or ads, according to their siteTheir Secret Santa page says “Free forever but installed in seconds”Free, no accounts, according to their page
Other points, from their pages/secretsanta status and remind (counts only); optional shipping address; wish list and anonymous messages on each private page (the bot does not carry the conversation); English and Spanish; up to 300 peopleSlack Connect across workspaces, scheduled delivery of the private messages, open source, and they say they have no database (data is forgotten a few hours after the last interaction). Their homepage states 31,608 Secret Santas organized with themEnrollment by DM, wishlists, plus Virtual Coffee and quizzes. They state “600,000+ employees from 40,000+ organizations”Wishlists, budget and date, a remind action that prepares a DM, and deletion 60 days after the event date

Where each one fits:

  • secret-santa.team if you also use Discord or Webex, want Slack Connect, scheduled messages, an open-source app or a Marketplace listing, or if the organizer should be able to see and reshuffle the draw.
  • Trivia if you want a broader team-bonding Slack app around the Secret Santa.
  • Fluky if you cannot (or would rather not) install a Slack app.
  • This app if you want the organizer never to see the result, status and remind commands, and the same website in Spanish as a fallback.

Europe

Americas

Asia and the Pacific

Guides

Frequently asked questions

Are these comparisons sponsored?

No. Nobody paid for them and there are no affiliate links. We make secretsanta.name, which is free.

How often are they updated?

Before each Christmas season, and whenever someone reports an error. Each page says when it was checked.

Guides

Create your Secret Santa draw