DrawNames alternative: an honest comparison (2026)
Create your Secret Santa draw Free, no signup needed, email optional.
DrawNames is a good, free tool, and if your group wants wish lists, a phone app and a gift finder, it is hard to beat. If you want something simpler, with no email address on the website, rules for couples and households even in small groups, and nobody seeing the full list unless you choose so, this generator is the alternative. Facts below are as of November 2026, taken from DrawNames' own pages.
DrawNames vs this generator at a glance
| DrawNames | secretsanta.name | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free (says no ads and no in-app purchases) | Free, no ads |
| Account to take part | No registration required | No (optional) |
| Email address | On the website each participant is tied to an email; its app works without email | No (optional, only to deliver the link) |
| How people get their name | Each person opens an invitation (email, text, WhatsApp) and draws a name; optional live draw | A private link per person that you share (WhatsApp, SMS, any chat), or an email we send if you add an address (optional) |
| Exclusions | Yes, several per person, for groups of at least 4 | Yes: households, one-way and two-way rules, up to 500; works from 3 people when possible |
| Impossible rules | Not documented | The solver explains why and which rule to drop |
| Who can see the full list | The organizer, after the celebration date | Organizer and participants with an account, after the date (opt-in); nobody by default |
| Avoid last year's matches | Yes, when you reuse a group | Yes, when you copy a draw or keep the group in an optional account |
| Wish lists | Yes | Yes |
| Gift finder | Yes | No |
| Anonymous questions | Yes | Yes, on the private page; the organizer can't read them |
| Phone apps | iOS and Android | No, works in any browser |
| Group size | No limit stated | Up to 300 |
Where DrawNames is better
- Gift finder and richer wish lists. Each participant can make a wish list with items from any shop, and there is a gift finder filtered by age, budget and category. Our wish lists are simpler (an idea, a link and a note) and we have no gift finder.
- Apps. DrawNames has iOS and Android apps, and its app lets people join without an email address.
- Live draw. Everyone can see whose name they drew at the same moment, which is fun on a video call.
- Big groups. It states no group limit; we stop at 300 people.
If those features matter to your group, use DrawNames. It is free and well made.
Where this generator is better
- No email on the web. Nobody has to type an address: you get one private link per person and send it on the chat you already use. Email is there if you want it, per person.
- Rules that always work or tell you why. We solve the draw with a SAT solver, so households (couples, families, flatmates), one-way and two-way rules are checked together. If no valid draw exists, you see which person is stuck and which single rule to remove.
- Rules in small groups. DrawNames' FAQ says exclusions need at least 4 people. Here you can add rules with 3 people when a draw is still possible.
- Anonymous messages the organizer can't open. Ask the person you give to, or write to your Santa. Their page says “your Secret Santa”, never your name, and there is no screen where the organizer can read the conversation.
- Nobody sees the full draw unless you choose so. DrawNames lets the organizer view the list after the celebration date. Here, by default, each person only ever sees their own name. Sharing the list after a date is an opt-in when you create the draw, and everyone is told on their private page.
- No reciprocal pairs by default. A gives to B and B gives back to A doesn't happen unless you allow it.
How the two work, step by step
DrawNames: the organizer enters the names, optional exclusions, a budget and a date, then sends invitations by email, text or a messaging app. Each participant accepts the invitation, draws a name and can fill in a wish list. The organizer sees who has drawn and who still has to.
secretsanta.name: the organizer types the names, ticks who lives together, adds any rules and presses Draw. The whole draw is done at once, on the server. Each person gets a private link; opening it shows nothing until they press a button, so chat previews can't spoil it. The organizer sees whether each link was opened, never the name inside.
What we don't do (so you can decide)
- Wish lists are simple (an idea, an optional link and a note). Anonymous messages are on each private page: you can ask the person you give to, and they can reply or write to their Santa. Your name stays hidden and the organizer cannot read the messages. No gift finder and no item reservations.
- No phone app. It works in any browser on a phone or computer.
- Up to 300 people per draw. A big office may need to split into teams.
- Names and results are stored on our server in readable form (not end-to-end encrypted), because that is how the private links work. Draws are deleted after 400 days, or sooner if the organizer deletes them.
- By default nobody sees who got whom. If the organizer opts in when creating the draw, the full list opens after a date they pick, and everyone is told on their private page. When the organizer sends the links personally they could open someone else's link. Adding each person's email avoids that: the link goes straight to them.
- The site is in English and Spanish only.
Switching from DrawNames
You don't need to export anything. Type the same names, tick the couples, and add last year's pairs if you want to avoid repeats (the form has a field for them). Next year, “Copy for next year” keeps people and rules and avoids the previous pairs automatically.
Start a free draw No signup. Takes about two minutes.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a DrawNames alternative that doesn't need email?
Yes. secretsanta.name gives each participant a private link you share on WhatsApp, SMS or any chat, so nobody types an email address (adding one is optional). DrawNames' own app also works without email; its website asks for one.
Can the organizer see who drew whom on DrawNames?
According to DrawNames' FAQ (as of November 2026), only the organizer can view the full list, and only after the celebration date. On secretsanta.name nobody can view it by default. The organizer can opt in when creating the draw; then, after the chosen date, the organizer and participants who saved their private link to an account can see it, and everyone is told in advance.
Does DrawNames support exclusions for couples?
Yes. Its FAQ says you can set several exclusions per person in groups of at least 4, and that you should set a couple's exclusion for both names. Here, ticking a couple in “Who lives together?” blocks both directions at once.
Is DrawNames free?
Yes. DrawNames says it is free, with no ads and no in-app purchases. secretsanta.name is free too, with no paid features.
Which is better for a family with wish lists?
Both have wish lists. On secretsanta.name each person writes theirs on their private page and only their Secret Santa sees it after the reveal. If you want a gift finder or item reservations too, DrawNames does more.