Elfster vs DrawNames: which one should you use?
Create your Secret Santa draw Free, no signup needed, email optional.
Both are free and both do the job. DrawNames is lighter: no registration, invitations by chat, and each person draws their own name. Elfster is a fuller platform built around accounts, wish lists and messages. If you want a simple draw with no accounts, there is a third option at the end. Everything here is as of November 2026, from each tool's own pages.
Side by side
| DrawNames | Elfster | secretsanta.name | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free (no ads, no in-app purchases, per DrawNames) | Free (earns commissions on gift links) | Free, no ads |
| Account to organize | No registration required | Yes | No (optional) |
| Participants | On the website, a name and email each; the app works without email | Invited by email or link; its pages differ on whether an account is needed to RSVP | No account or email needed |
| Who draws | Each participant, from their invitation; optional live draw | Elfster draws for everyone and emails each match | Drawn at once by a solver; each person opens a private link |
| Exclusions | Yes, groups of 4+ | Yes | Households, one-way and two-way rules |
| Full list visible to | Organizer, after the celebration date | Nobody | Organizer and participants with an account, after the date (opt-in); nobody by default |
| Wish lists | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Anonymous messages | Anonymous questions | Anonymous messages | Yes: Santa stays anonymous; the organizer can't read them |
| Apps | iOS, Android | iOS, Android | Browser only |
| Avoid last year's pairs | Yes, reusing a group | Exclusion pairs can be set | Yes, copying a draw or keeping the group |
Choose DrawNames if…
- you want people to join from a WhatsApp or text invitation without creating accounts;
- you like the idea of everyone drawing at the same time (live draw) on a video call;
- you want wish lists and a gift finder, but not a full social platform;
- you're fine with the organizer being able to see the full list after the party.
Choose Elfster if…
- your group already uses Elfster wish lists through the year;
- you need mailing addresses for shipped gifts, or reminder emails before the date;
- you want reminder emails before the exchange date;
- the organizer doesn't mind creating an account.
Choose a plain generator (like this one) if…
- nobody wants another account, and you'd rather not collect email addresses;
- your rules are tricky: several couples, a big household, one-way rules, last year's pairs. A solver checks them all at once and tells you when a draw is impossible and why;
- you want nobody to see the full list (the default), or to share it only after the date and tell everyone in advance;
- your group is 300 people or fewer and simple wish lists are enough.
Start a free draw No signup. Takes about two minutes.
The main differences, explained
Who draws. On DrawNames each person draws their own name from their invitation, so the draw finishes when the last person clicks. Elfster draws for everyone once the organizer is ready. Here the whole draw is solved at once when you press Draw, and each person just opens their link.
Privacy. DrawNames' FAQ says the organizer can view all drawn names after the celebration date. Elfster says the organizer can't see assignments. Here nobody can see it by default; the organizer can opt in at creation to share it after a date, and every private page says so.
Data. Elfster and DrawNames (on the web) work with email addresses. This generator only needs names, with email optional per person.
What a plain generator doesn't do
- Wish lists are simple (an idea, an optional link and a note). Anonymous messages are on each private page: you can ask the person you give to, and they can reply or write to their Santa. Your name stays hidden and the organizer cannot read the messages. No gift finder and no item reservations.
- No phone app. It works in any browser on a phone or computer.
- Up to 300 people per draw. A big office may need to split into teams.
- Names and results are stored on our server in readable form (not end-to-end encrypted), because that is how the private links work. Draws are deleted after 400 days, or sooner if the organizer deletes them.
- By default nobody sees who got whom. If the organizer opts in when creating the draw, the full list opens after a date they pick, and everyone is told on their private page. When the organizer sends the links personally they could open someone else's link. Adding each person's email avoids that: the link goes straight to them.
- The site is in English and Spanish only.
Frequently asked questions
Is Elfster or DrawNames better?
Neither is better for everyone. DrawNames is lighter and needs no registration; Elfster has more features around wish lists, messages and shipping, and needs an account to organize.
Do Elfster and DrawNames cost money?
No. Both are free as of November 2026. DrawNames says it has no ads or in-app purchases; Elfster says it may earn commissions on gift links.
Which one hides the results from the organizer?
Elfster says the organizer never sees assignments. DrawNames lets the organizer view the full list after the celebration date. secretsanta.name shows it to nobody by default; sharing it after a date is an opt-in at creation that everyone is told about.
Which works without email?
DrawNames' app works without email; on its website each participant has an email. Elfster works with email or a link, and people without email need a Family Manager account. secretsanta.name needs no email at all.
Is there a simpler option than both?
Yes. If you only need a fair draw with couples kept apart, secretsanta.name does it with no signup, no email and private links.
Sources
- drawnames.com: home page and app page
- drawnames.com: Set exclusions for Secret Santa (FAQ)
- drawnames.com: Never draw your own name (who can view drawn names)
- Elfster: How Elfster works
- Elfster Help Center: How do I join an Elfster Gift Exchange?
- Elfster Help Center: How do I invite someone without an email address?
- elfster.com home page (affiliate disclosure)