Thieving (or stealing) Secret Santa: how it works

Create your Secret Santa draw Free, no signup needed, email optional.

"Thieving Secret Santa" (also "Stealing Secret Santa") is Wikipedia's heading for the white elephant game: each participant brings one gift suitable for anyone, and players take turns opening a new gift or stealing a previously opened one. Wikipedia calls it "this completely different game" from classic Secret Santa and notes it's "more commonly known as the white elephant gift exchange, or Yankee Swap".

What makes it different from Secret Santa

  • Gifts are brought for the group, wrapped to disguise them; ideally the giver is not disclosed.
  • No one buys for a named person; ownership is decided by the steals.
  • Rules and steal limits: see White Elephant.

Not to be confused with a "stolen Santa" joke

The Irish Times mentions a Kris Kindle twist where gifts are supposed to be "illegally procured" - in practice, stationery. That's a gag on a normal name draw, not the steal game. See Kris Kindle.

All the names for the steal game

White Elephant, Yankee Swap, Dirty Santa, Thieving/Stealing Secret Santa, Grab Bag (per Wikipedia), Chinese gift exchange. Pages: Yankee Swap, Dirty Santa, Chinese gift exchange. For the comparison table, Secret Santa vs White Elephant vs Kris Kringle vs Pollyanna.

Run it with the generator

secretsanta.name draws the names for you: nobody gets themselves, couples and households can be kept apart, and each person gets a private link to reveal their match. It's free, there's no signup, and nobody needs an email address.

Frequently asked questions

What is Thieving Secret Santa?

Wikipedia's name for the white elephant / Yankee swap game: each player brings one gift and may open a new one or steal a previously opened gift.

Is it the same as Secret Santa?

No. Wikipedia calls it a 'completely different game'.

What is the 'stolen Santa' in Kris Kindle?

The Irish Times mentions a Kris Kindle variation where gifts are meant to be 'illegally' procured, in offices usually from the stationery cupboard. It is a joke twist, not the White Elephant rules.

Create your Secret Santa draw