Secret Santa vs White Elephant vs Kris Kringle vs Pollyanna: what's the difference?

Create your Secret Santa draw Free, no signup needed, email optional.

Secret Santa, Kris Kringle and Pollyanna are name draws: you secretly draw one person and buy a gift for them. White Elephant, Yankee Swap, Dirty Santa and the "Chinese gift exchange" are steal games: everyone brings a wrapped gift and players open or steal. The confusion comes from the names being used loosely: Wikipedia even lists "Thieving Secret Santa" as another name for the steal game.

At a glance

Secret Santa Kris Kringle / Kris Kindle Pollyanna White Elephant Yankee Swap Dirty Santa Chinese gift exchange
Type Name draw Name draw Name draw (sometimes gift draw) Steal game Steal game Steal game Steal game
Where the name is used US, UK, global Australia, Ireland (Kindle), parts of Canada Pennsylvania, Baltimore US, Canada New England US Canada, parts of the US
Who gets which gift Chosen for one named person Same Same Whoever holds it at the end Same Same Same
Gift style Personal, to a budget Same Same Often funny or impractical More often practical (per Wikipedia) Same as White Elephant Same
Needs a draw beforehand Yes Yes Yes Only for turn order Same Same Same
Giver secret? Until the reveal Same Sometimes a guessing game Gifts are anonymous, steals are public Same Same Same

Name draws

  • Secret Santa is the baseline. Members of a group are randomly assigned a person to give a gift to; the giver may stay secret or be revealed at the end.
  • Kris Kringle is the Australian name for it, per Wikipedia, and in Canada the two names are used alongside each other. See Kris Kringle.
  • Pollyanna is mainly a Pennsylvania/Baltimore word. World Wide Words, quoting the Dictionary of American Regional English, says the full phrase "Pollyanna gift exchange" appears in newspapers from about 1947. See Pollyanna.

Steal games

Wikipedia defines a white elephant exchange, Yankee swap or Dirty Santa as a party game where amusing and impractical gifts are exchanged; players open gifts or steal opened ones. In a Yankee swap, the gifts are more likely to be practical. Standard rules are in White Elephant. Name stories are in Yankee Swap, Dirty Santa and Chinese gift exchange.

Why the names get mixed up

  • Some older sources describe a wrapped-gift draw as Pollyanna, and Wikipedia lists Yankee Swap, White Elephant and Dirty Santa under "Thieving Secret Santa", so a name can point to either game.
  • Another list adds "Rob Your Neighbor" (the Midwest) and "Thieves' Christmas" for the steal game.
  • "Chinese gift exchange" is reported as a misconception-based name with no known Chinese origin, and some people find it offensive, so many hosts use White Elephant on the invitation.

Which to pick

  • Fair, budget-friendly, remote or hybrid teams: a name draw. Each person gets something chosen for them, and exclusions (couples, housemates) are easy to add.
  • In-person party where laughter matters more than the gift: a steal game.
  • Not sure: do a name draw for the real gifts and a steal game on the night for silly ones.

Run it with the generator

secretsanta.name draws the names for you: nobody gets themselves, couples and households can be kept apart, and each person gets a private link to reveal their match. It's free, there's no signup, and nobody needs an email address.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Secret Santa and White Elephant?

In Secret Santa you draw one person's name and buy a gift chosen for them. In White Elephant everyone brings one wrapped gift to a pile and players take turns opening a new gift or stealing an opened one, so the gift belongs to whoever holds it at the end.

Is Kris Kringle the same as Secret Santa?

Yes. Kris Kringle is the Australian (and in places Canadian) name for the same name-draw gift exchange; Ireland uses Kris Kindle.

Is Yankee Swap the same as White Elephant?

They describe the same open-or-steal game. Yankee Swap is the New England name; some sources say Yankee Swap gifts tend to be more practical and White Elephant gifts more amusing.

What is a Pollyanna gift exchange?

A regional American name (mainly Pennsylvania and Baltimore) for a Secret-Santa-style exchange; it can also describe a draw of wrapped gifts.

Which should I choose for a work party?

Use a name draw (Secret Santa/Kris Kringle) when you want each person to get something chosen for them and it must be fair on a budget. Use a steal game when you want a lively in-person party and don't mind a gift being stolen.

Create your Secret Santa draw