What is a Pollyanna gift exchange?

Create your Secret Santa draw Free, no signup needed, email optional.

A Pollyanna is a gift exchange where each person gives one gift to one other member of the group, often under a price ceiling. World Wide Words, quoting the Dictionary of American Regional English (DARE), says it is now mainly heard in and around Pennsylvania and is used by offices, clubs and large families. The German Wikipedia's Wichteln article adds Baltimore.

How it is done

World Wide Words describes two ways: people draw lots to decide who buys for whom (sometimes recipients guess the giver), or each person brings a wrapped gift and recipients draw lots for which gift they get. Both giver and receiver may be called "the pollyanna". The first is Secret Santa under another name; the second is closer to White Elephant.

History of the word

  • The full phrase "Pollyanna gift exchange" turns up in newspapers from about 1947, according to World Wide Words, but now seems almost extinct.
  • World Wide Words finds nothing explaining the name, but notes a lack of references before 1916 and suggests it was named after Eleanor Hodgman Porter's Pollyanna (1913), whose heroine teaches a town the "glad game".
  • The Expday guide points out that Pollyanna clubs, often linked to churches, appear in American newspapers from 1916 and says plainly that nothing documents the step from book to gift exchange. We say the same: the book link is a guess.
  • Not to be confused with the other, more common sense of "pollyanna": an excessively cheerful person.

Compared with other names

See Secret Santa vs White Elephant vs Kris Kringle vs Pollyanna and Secret Santa around the world.

Run it with the generator

secretsanta.name draws the names for you: nobody gets themselves, couples and households can be kept apart, and each person gets a private link to reveal their match. It's free, there's no signup, and nobody needs an email address.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Pollyanna gift exchange?

A regional American name for a gift exchange in which each person gives one gift to one other person in the group, often under a price ceiling. It is heard mainly in and around Pennsylvania.

Where does the name Pollyanna come from here?

Unknown. World Wide Words suggests it was named after Eleanor Hodgman Porter's 1913 novel Pollyanna and its 'glad game', but no source documents the link.

Is a Pollyanna the same as Secret Santa?

Mostly yes. It can also mean a draw of wrapped gifts rather than a draw of names.

Is the term known in the UK?

World Wide Words says it is not known in the UK.

Create your Secret Santa draw