How to host a cookie exchange: how many cookies, how many guests, what rules

Create your Secret Santa draw Free, no signup needed, email optional.

A cookie exchange (or cookie swap) is a party where each guest bakes a big batch of one cookie and trades, so everyone goes home with an assortment. It is not a name draw: everyone gives to everyone, unlike Secret Santa.

How many cookies?

  • Classic rule: a dozen identical cookies for each guest, plus a dozen to share at the party. SignUp.com's example: 9 attendees plus the host means 10 dozen each, and everyone leaves with 9 dozen assorted.
  • Scaling down: Real Simple says a half dozen per guest works for more than 10 people or if you want a sampler. Martha Stewart says most hosts ask a dozen per person, but scaling down is fine.
  • Twist Invite's table: 4 to 6 guests, a dozen per guest; 7 to 10 guests, six dozen plus a dozen to taste; 11 to 16 guests, four to six dozen plus a plate to taste; 17 or more, split into two swap tables or ask for three dozen each.

How many guests, how much notice

Keep the guest list small: 10 or fewer (SignUp.com), eight to 10 (Real Simple), about eight (Martha Stewart), six to eight (DoorDash). Invitations: at least 10 days ahead (SignUp.com) or three to four weeks in the busy season (Martha Stewart).

Rules worth stating on the invitation

Twist Invite's template: one kind of cookie per guest, all from the same recipe; claim your cookie when you RSVP so there are no duplicates; say whether homemade only; bring a container; label nuts and other common allergens; bring recipe cards or a photo of the recipe; optional vote for a favourite. SignUp.com adds "party rules" such as home-baked only, strictly cookies, or bars and candies allowed. Martha Stewart suggests letting guests sign up for a category as a compromise between assigning and free choice. Real Simple suggests asking everyone to name their cookie and say where the recipe came from.

How the swap works

Twist Invite: one table for trays, one for tasting; guests walk the table taking a few cookies from each tray per round until the trays are empty. DoorDash's host does it differently: gift bags labelled with each guest's name, where each person puts a dozen into every bag.

Adding a Secret Santa

If the group also wants a name-draw gift exchange, that is a separate game. secretsanta.name draws names for you: nobody gets themselves, couples and households can be kept apart, and each person gets a private link. It's free, there's no signup, and nobody needs an email address. You can put "something baked" in the message everyone sees. For more themes, see themed Secret Santa ideas.

Run it with the generator

Use the generator only for the gift draw. The cookie swap itself needs no draw.

Frequently asked questions

How does a cookie exchange work?

Guests each bake a batch of one cookie and trade, so everyone leaves with an assortment. SignUp.com describes one dozen identical cookies for each guest plus a dozen to share at the party.

How many cookies should each person bring?

Guides say a dozen per guest. Real Simple suggests a half dozen per guest if there are more than 10 participants; Twist Invite gives a table by group size, such as six dozen for 7 to 10 guests.

How many people should you invite?

SignUp.com says 10 guests or fewer; Real Simple 8 to 10; Martha Stewart says experienced hosts cap at around eight; DoorDash's host keeps it to six to eight.

How far ahead should you send invitations?

SignUp.com says at least 10 days; Martha Stewart suggests three to four weeks in the busy holiday season.

Is a cookie exchange a Secret Santa?

No. A cookie exchange has no name draw; everyone gives to everyone.

Create your Secret Santa draw