Book exchange Secret Santa: five formats and the rules that make them work
Create your Secret Santa draw Free, no signup needed, email optional.
A book exchange is a gift exchange where the gift must be a book, and it can be run as a drawn-names Secret Santa, a blind-date-with-a-book table, a white elephant or a shelf swap. Secret.gift lists five formats and says they aren't interchangeable: pick by what your group is like.
The five formats (secret.gift)
| Format | How it works | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Drawn pairs (book Secret Santa) | Names drawn in advance; each person buys for one specific reader | Needs about a week of lead time |
| Blind date with a book | Books wrapped in plain paper, three hint words outside; people pick by the hints | Vague hints such as "good" |
| White elephant books | Wrapped books in a pile, numbered turns, stealing allowed | Someone ends up with a book nobody wanted |
| Shelf swap | Everyone brings a book they already own and loved | People offloading books they disliked |
| Wrapped and random | One wrapped book each, pulled blind from a bag | Pure chance |
Rules for a drawn-names book exchange
- Draw early. Secret.gift says a week or two ahead; Pindao says two weeks, because a book chosen for a person is the whole point.
- One book, one opinion. Pindao suggests a ceiling if you like, with the real rule that the giver has an opinion about the book. Elfster's version: it must be a book you have read and would genuinely recommend.
- Write why inside the cover. Both secret.gift and Pindao suggest one or two lines; Elfster calls the handwritten note "the real gift".
- No spoilers and no deadlines. Pindao: a book is a gift, not homework.
- Avoid sequels unless you're sure the person has read the earlier books.
Blind date with a book: hints and swapping
Secret.gift suggests three to five words on the outside (genre, mood, a hook) and banning "good", "amazing" and "classic"; content warnings go outside in brackets. Librarius suggests three to seven clue words, agreeing minimum condition (no mold or loose pages) and whether a swap is compulsory or one rejection is allowed, and offers formats such as numbered rounds, a raffle or an open table. Pindao notes it works well at a party but less as a draw, because the gift is no longer for a specific person.
Themes on top
Elfster mentions genre-restricted exchanges (fiction, non-fiction, fantasy), format-specific ones (hardcover only) or author-specific ones such as local or debut authors. Pindao suggests books from before you were born, under 150 pages, or recommended to you by someone else. More in themed Secret Santa ideas; for the stealing format see White Elephant.
Run it with the generator
For the drawn-names format, secretsanta.name draws the names for you: nobody gets themselves, couples and households can be kept apart, and each person gets a private link to reveal their match. It's free, there's no signup, and nobody needs an email address. You can set the budget, date and a message such as "a book only". Blind-date and white-elephant formats don't use a name draw.
Frequently asked questions
What is a book exchange Secret Santa?
A normal Secret Santa where the only constraint is that the gift is a book. Names are drawn a week or two ahead and each person buys one book for one named person, according to secret.gift.
What are the rules?
Common rules in the guides we read: one book each, a price ceiling, only books the giver has an opinion about (Elfster says one you have read and would recommend), a note inside the cover on why you chose it, and no spoilers or reading deadlines.
What is a blind date with a book?
Each book is wrapped so the cover is hidden and hint words are written on the outside; people choose a package by the hints. Secret.gift suggests three to five words and Librarius three to seven.
Can you do a book exchange as a white elephant?
Yes. Elfster says a book exchange can be run as Secret Santa or White Elephant, and secret.gift lists a white elephant format with numbered turns and stealing.
Are used books allowed?
Decide and say so up front. Pindao says a shelf swap with books you own needs a group that won't treat a used book as a lesser gift; Librarius suggests a minimum condition.